Methodology
How we establish, label and correct evidence
We establish what is known, what changed, which institutions are responsible, where evidence conflicts and which questions remain unresolved. We do not forecast and we do not advise: the decision stays with the reader, or with the organisation and adviser it belongs to.
Seats of power, not personalities
We cover offices and institutions — ministries, state governments, regulators, missions — rather than individuals. An officeholder is named only as the current holder of a seat. This keeps the record durable and non-partisan.
Source tiers
Every claim carries the tier of its evidence, strongest first:
- Official — primary documents and government websites: ministries, state departments, gazettes, PIB, the India Semiconductor Mission and similar.
- Reference — encyclopaedic and background sources.
- News — aggregated open news signal (GDELT and outlet reporting).
- Analysis — IndiaStand's own synthesis, always labelled as such, never presented as fact.
Verification statuses
Separately from its tier, each claim on a comparison or tracker states how strongly it is established:
- Verified
- Read directly in an official primary (a ministry, state department, gazette or PIB release), or confirmed by two independent origins. Our own analysis is never "verified".
- Single source
- One non-official source. Plausible, not yet corroborated.
- Reported
- News reporting only. Several articles repeating one press release count as one origin, not several confirmations.
- Unverified
- Asserted somewhere we could not check against a source.
- Contradicted
- Sources disagree. The page says where, and attributes each position.
- Unknown
- We could not establish it from the documents available to us. Unknown is not "no", and missing coverage is not evidence that nothing changed.
Implementation is a sequence of separate claims
A scheme can be announced without being notified, notified without an application process, and open without evidence that anything has been approved under it. Our trackers record each stage that is documented — proposed, announced, formally issued, effective, application process available, implementation evidenced, amended or withdrawn — and show the stages we cannot evidence as not evidenced. Projects follow their own lifecycle: announced, approved, land allotted, construction started, pilot output, commercial operation. An inauguration is not, by itself, evidence of volume production.
Four dates, kept apart
- Event date
- When the documented state held — "as of" on a claim.
- Source publication date
- When the source itself was published.
- Sources checked
- When we last re-read the sources behind a page. Shown only when a check actually ran, with its result: no material change, a change under review, or a source that could not be reached.
- Updated
- When a claim, answer or summary on the page last changed in substance. This is the date in the page metadata and the sitemap. We never re-stamp a date to make a page look fresh.
Comparisons describe; they do not rank
Our comparisons set jurisdictions against defined criteria, every cell sourced. There is no score, total or "best" column: which criteria matter, and how much, depends on the decision. Where we publish a ranking elsewhere on the site, it states its signal and window and describes attention or salience — it is not an endorsement.
How research is produced
Open sources are monitored by automated editorial cycles — official feeds first, then news — and every pull is kept for provenance. Agents assemble existing evidence, identify gaps and draft; consequential interpretations, contradictions and whether each citation actually supports its claim are reviewed by a person before anything is delivered to a client. No paid data sources, no paywalled content reproduced, and no privileged or confidential government material, ever.
Confidentiality and reuse
Client questions, documents, plans and discussions are kept in a private workspace, separate from this site. A commission can tell us which public question is worth investigating; it never automatically becomes a public page that would reveal a client's strategy. Client-specific work is reused only under rights agreed with the client, and public facts are re-sourced independently.
Corrections
If a claim is wrong, out of date or weaker than its label says, tell us with the source and we will re-check it against the primary. Corrections change the claim, its status and its date; we do not silently rewrite. Send a correction.
Questions about the method
- How does IndiaStand decide whether a claim is verified?
- A claim is verified only when it has been read in an official primary source or confirmed by two independent origins. Re-reports of a single press release count as one origin. IndiaStand analysis is never labelled verified.
- Does an official announcement prove a scheme is operational?
- No. An official announcement is strong evidence that an announcement occurred. IndiaStand trackers record each lifecycle stage — announced, formally issued, effective, application process available, implementation evidenced — as a separate claim with its own evidence.
- What does "Sources checked" mean on an IndiaStand page?
- It is the date the sources behind the page were last re-read, with the result of that check. It appears only when a check actually ran, and it is separate from the date the page was last substantively updated.