Skip to content
IndiaStand

Coverage

Institutions

Maintained dossiers on the constitutional bodies and regulators of the Republic — what each is empowered to do, and the article or Act that empowers it.

3 maintained dossiers, each carrying a timeline from 1947 or its founding, its sources tiered by provenance, and the questions readers ask about it answered on the page.

What the bodies on this desk have in common is that none of them is a ministry, and each was brought into being by a different instrument. The Election Commission of India is a permanent constitutional body: Article 324 vests the superintendence, direction and control of elections to Parliament, the state legislatures, the office of President and the office of Vice-President in it. Parliament is the Union legislature under Article 79, consisting of the President and the two Houses — the Council of States and the House of the People. The Reserve Bank of India is a statutory corporation established by the Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934, and is the country’s monetary authority and banknote issuer.

Because the instrument differs, so does the accountability. A constitutional body answers to the Constitution and the courts; a statutory one answers to the Act that made it and to the ministry that administers that Act. Each dossier is written in those terms: what the body may do, under what authority, and what it has actually done.

That distinction is worth holding on to when reading about any of them. A ministry can be reorganised by an executive order rewriting the allocation of business; a statutory body needs an amending Act; a constitutional body needs a constitutional amendment, and in some cases a removal procedure modelled on the one for a judge of the Supreme Court. The difficulty of changing an institution is a good first approximation of how independent it is, and it is set at the moment the institution is created rather than negotiated afterwards.

Tenure is where that difference becomes concrete, and the three bodies here are protected in three different ways. The Chief Election Commissioner may not be removed except in the same manner and on the same grounds as a judge of the Supreme Court, which is the strongest protection the Constitution gives any appointed officeholder outside the judiciary. The Governor of the Reserve Bank holds office for a term fixed by the Central Government under the Act that created the Bank, and is appointed by it. Members of Parliament hold office by election, for five years in the lower House and for staggered six-year terms in the upper one, where a third of the seats turn over every two years so the chamber is never wholly renewed at once.

This desk is the smallest of the five and is being built out deliberately rather than quickly, because the class is broad: the regulators of securities, telecommunications, insurance, competition and electricity all belong here, as do the Comptroller and Auditor General, the Union Public Service Commission, the National Human Rights Commission and the recognised political parties. A dossier is published when its timeline, its official sources and its answers are complete enough to be worth citing — the coverage counter above is the honest number, not a target.