Skip to content
IndiaStand
Topic brief · maintained 2026-07-06 · updated 2026-10-07

India's judiciary: appointments, pendency and reform

India is almost the only major democracy in which the higher judiciary chooses its own judges — through the collegium, a creature of Supreme Court judgments rather than statute. Parliament's attempt to replace it with a National Judicial Appointments Commission was struck down in 2015, and the collegium has run ever since without a finalised Memorandum of Procedure. On top sits a pendency crisis — more than 5.6 crore cases across all courts and about 95,000 at the Supreme Court — which drove the 2026 expansion of the Court from 34 to 38 judges, now enacted by Parliament; with the October 2026 appointments, 37 seats are filled. The Court is meanwhile adjudicating another appointments contest, over the panel that selects the Election Commission. This is the maintained topic brief on where it stands as of 2026-10-07.

More than 5.6 crore (over 56 million) cases are pending across all of India's courts, per the National Judicial Data Grid.

Judiciary of IndiaElection Commission of India

The question that never closes: who appoints judges

Every dispute about the Indian judiciary’s independence ultimately returns to a single question — who chooses its judges. In India the answer is the courts themselves. Appointments to the Supreme Court and the High Courts are decided by the collegium, a body of the senior-most judges headed by the Chief Justice of India, whose recommendations the executive can delay or return once but cannot, by convention, ultimately refuse. This makes India, as the reference record on the NJAC notes, one of the very few democracies where the higher judiciary effectively selects its own members. The collegium is not written into the Constitution; it is a construct of Supreme Court judgments, which is precisely why its legitimacy is perennially contested.

The collegium, in three judgments

The system was built in three steps, all of them interpretations of the word “consultation” in Articles 124 and 217 of the Constitution. In the First Judges Case (1981) the Court read consultation as leaving the last word with the executive. In the Second Judges Case (1993) it reversed itself, holding that “consultation” with the Chief Justice means concurrence, and inventing the collegium to give the judiciary primacy. The Third Judges Case (1998), a Presidential Reference, fixed the collegium’s membership: Supreme Court appointments are settled by the CJI plus the four senior-most judges, and High Court appointments by the CJI plus the two senior-most judges — the structure set out in the reference record. That framework has governed appointments ever since.

NJAC: Parliament’s challenge, and its defeat

In August 2014 Parliament tried to end the collegium. The 99th Constitutional Amendment and the National Judicial Appointments Commission Act, 2014 were passed near-unanimously by both Houses and would have replaced the collegium with a six-member commission — the CJI, two senior judges, the Union Law Minister, and two “eminent persons” chosen by a panel of the CJI, the Prime Minister and the Leader of the Opposition, per the reference record. On 16 October 2015, in the Fourth Judges Case (Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association v. Union of India), a Constitution Bench struck the NJAC down by 4:1, holding that giving the executive a role in appointments violated the basic structure — the independence of the judiciary — with the lone dissent warning that the collegium was itself opaque. The collegium was restored, and no legislative replacement has been enacted since.

The unfinished rulebook: the Memorandum of Procedure

The 2015 judgment did not end there. In a supplementary order the Court invited the government to revise the Memorandum of Procedure (MoP) — the document that governs how the collegium and the executive actually process an appointment — “in consultation with the Chief Justice of India”. More than a decade later that revision remains unfinalised. Reporting on the tussle, including ThePrint’s explainer on the Memorandum of Procedure, records a standing deadlock over the terms: the government has pressed for provisions such as a “national security” ground on which a recommended name could be returned, the Parliamentary Standing Committee on law and justice warned that such clauses could amount to a government veto over appointments, and the collegium rejected the contested clauses and held that the existing MoP was final. Because a revised MoP was never settled, the collegium continues to operate under the pre-2015 memorandum, and each contested appointment is negotiated against an unfinished rulebook.

The backlog: the numbers

Running alongside the appointments contest is a pendency crisis. Across all three tiers — the Supreme Court, the High Courts and the district and subordinate courts — more than 5.6 crore (over 56 million) cases are pending, the great majority of them in the district and subordinate courts, per the reference tally on pendency (which cites the National Judicial Data Grid) and the consolidated figures published on the government’s National Judicial Data Grid. At the apex, pendency has hit records. The Supreme Court Observer’s docket tracking recorded 93,143 cases at the end of March 2026, then a rise through the partial working days of June and July to 95,718, a fall to 94,639 at the end of August — the first month since early in the year in which disposals exceeded institutions — and 94,961 at the end of September on the Court’s Justice Clock. The two counts come from NJDG and the Justice Clock respectively and are not perfectly comparable. PRS Legislative Research ties the backlog to judicial vacancies — High Court judgeships have run close to a third vacant in recent years — so the appointments question and the pendency question are two faces of one problem.

The 2026 expansion: 34 to 38, and filling it

The most concrete institutional response of 2026 was to enlarge the apex court. An ordinance of 16 May 2026 raised the sanctioned strength from 34 to 38 including the Chief Justice — the first change since 2019 — and Parliament replaced it in the Monsoon Session with the Supreme Court (Number of Judges) Amendment Act, 2026. In the Rajya Sabha debate the Law Minister said the proposal began with a letter from the Chief Justice to the Prime Minister citing case inflow and the load of Constitution Bench work.

The collegium moved quickly to fill the seats. It recommended four High Court Chief Justices and a senior advocate on 27 May; the Union cleared all five within four days and they were sworn in on 2 June. Retirements then brought the Court back to 34, and on 28 September the collegium recommended the Chief Justices of the Gujarat, Delhi and Telangana High Courts; the Union notified the appointments in early October, taking the Court to 37 of 38. In both rounds the Union acted on the collegium’s recommendations within days.

The other appointments contest before the Court

The Supreme Court is also the forum for a second dispute about who appoints an independent institution. The 2023 Act on the Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioners replaced the Chief Justice on the selection panel with a Cabinet Minister nominated by the Prime Minister. On 23 September 2026 a two-judge bench split on the Union’s request to send the challenge to a larger bench: Justice Dipankar Datta declined and observed that the committee’s composition appeared to give the executive a veto, while Justice Satish Chandra Sharma held that the question whether Parliament may replace the Chief Justice with a minister needs a Constitution Bench. The matter is with the Chief Justice to constitute a bench; a recall application and a curative petition have since been filed. The argument mirrors the NJAC one in reverse — there the judiciary resisted an executive role in choosing judges; here petitioners ask the Court to restore a judicial role in choosing election commissioners.

The accountability flashpoint

The collegium’s critics have long argued it is opaque and unaccountable, and a 2025 controversy over the discovery of cash at a High Court judge’s official residence — which triggered an in-house inquiry — reignited that argument, as ThePrint documented. It revived open calls from within the executive to bring back a commission on NJAC lines: the office of the Vice President, in early 2025, publicly described the NJAC as “a visionary step endorsed by Parliament” and questioned the collegium, per the same reporting. The judiciary’s position, reflected in the 2015 majority and reasserted since, is that its primacy in appointments is part of the basic structure and cannot be surrendered to the executive.

The range of positions, attributed

The contest is genuinely three-cornered, and the brief characterises the actual positions rather than adjudicating between them:

  • The judiciary’s position. Judicial primacy in appointments is a facet of independence and part of the Constitution’s basic structure; this is the ratio of the 2015 Fourth Judges majority recorded in the NJAC case reference.
  • The executive’s position. No institution should select its own members without external checks; the NJAC was a democratically enacted reform, and provisions such as a national-security ground and greater transparency belong in the appointments process — the view associated with the office of the Vice President and the Union executive, per ThePrint.
  • The internal-critique position. Even judges in the 2015 majority have since acknowledged the collegium’s opacity; the recurring argument here is that the collegium needs a written, transparent procedure — the still-unfinalised MoP — rather than abolition, a strand also traced in ThePrint’s account.

This is, throughout, a domestic constitutional argument — a contest between the executive and the judiciary over the boundary between accountability and independence — with none of the domestic-versus-foreign framing divergence that marks India’s geopolitical files.

Who owns this topic (and why we’re here)

A search for “collegium vs NJAC” or “Supreme Court case pendency” today surfaces two layers and a gap. The primary layer — the Supreme Court site, the Department of Justice NJDG and PRS vital statistics — carries authoritative numbers but no narrative. The exam-prep and explainer layer explains the collegium-vs-NJAC history cleanly for aspirants but is static, undated on the live dispute, and thinly sourced. What is missing is a single maintained, provenance-intact state-of-play that ties the three judgments, the NJAC defeat, the deadlocked MoP, the pendency numbers and the 2026 expansion into one thread. That is the gap this brief fills, anchored to a structured Judiciary of India dossier and read alongside the Election Commission as the two institutions whose independence is contested through their appointment machinery.

Maintained topic brief. Analysis by IndiaStand — it characterises the state of play and the range of positions actually held, attributes each claim, and makes no forecast and no recommendation.

Sources

  1. Supreme Court of India (official) · India
  2. National Judicial Data Grid — Department of Justice · India
  3. National Judicial Appointments Commission (reference) · India
  4. Pendency and Vacancies in the Judiciary — PRS Legislative Research · India
  5. March 2026: pendency climbs to over 93,000 cases — Supreme Court Observer · India
  6. Members of the Supreme Court Collegium, June 2026 — Supreme Court Observer · India
  7. Ordinance lifts SC strength to 38 — Supreme Court Observer · India
  8. President assents to Supreme Court (Number of Judges) Amendment Act, 2026 — LawBeat · India
  9. Supreme Court strength rises to 37 as five new judges are sworn in — LawBeat · India
  10. Three new judges recommended for the Supreme Court — Supreme Court Observer · India
  11. Centre notifies appointment of 3 new Supreme Court judges — Indian Masterminds · India
  12. August 2026: pendency decreases by 1079 cases — Supreme Court Observer · India
  13. Monsoon session review 2026 — Supreme Court Observer · India
  14. Supreme Court split verdict on pleas challenging CEC appointment law — ANI · India
  15. Cabinet clears Bill to expand Supreme Court strength to 38 — Supreme Court Observer · India
  16. What's the Memorandum of Procedure, and why it's at the heart of the govt-SC tussle — ThePrint · India
  17. Judge cash row reignites judicial appointments debate — ThePrint · India
  18. Pendency of court cases in India (reference) · India

For organisations

Need this for a decision your organisation is making?

We establish what is documented, what changed, who is responsible, where evidence conflicts and what remains unknown. We do not give investment, legal or policy advice — the decision stays with you or your adviser. Services · Methodology